RU KZ EN Full case file (Russian) →
Case summary · Republic of Kazakhstan

The contract was declared void.
The tax stayed on the books.

In 2023 a Kazakhstani court, at the tax authority's own request, declared a contract of Network Administrator LLP void. The law spells out the tax consequences of a void transaction for the buyer — but not for the seller. This page is a factual summary; the complete case file, with all primary documents, is in Russian.

On 28 April 2023 the Specialised Inter-District Economic Court of the Karaganda Region (case no. 3514-23-00-2/894), on a claim brought by the tax authority, declared void the contract between Network Administrator LLP (ТОО «Администратор сети», business ID 110940015825) and Karagandy Zharyk LLP (ТОО «Қарағанды Жарық»); the company was the defendant. The judgment became final on 19 July 2023. Its operative part declares only the contract void and does not determine tax consequences. For the buyer, the Tax Code spells them out (VAT is excluded from the offset, expenses from deductions); for the seller there is no equivalent rule. VAT of 20,400,000 tenge on the related e-invoice of 30 April 2020 is still recorded as accrued. The company filed corrective VAT returns three times (11 December 2023, 14 February 2024, 31 July 2024); the authorities registered none of them. The Ministry of Finance holds that the limitation period expired on 30 June 2023, before the judgment took effect; the company maintains that it was extended until a desk-audit notice was complied with. Over five years the company filed 42 formal petitions to state bodies and received its first response on the merits only on 14 July 2026.

Key figures

20.4 m ₸VAT on the disputed e-invoice, still recorded as accrued
34 monthsof restrictions on bank operations and electronic invoicing (March 2021 – January 2024)
3corrective tax returns filed (Dec 2023, Feb 2024, Jul 2024); none registered
42formal petitions to state bodies, 2022–2026 (the company's count)
92.6 m ₸contract terminated by agreement on 21 Dec 2023 — SCADA design supervision for a regional power utility
167,949,136 ₸value of the civil claim for damages (returned by the court on 27 Jul 2026; private appeal filed)

Timeline

  1. March 2021Spending operations on the company's bank accounts are suspended and electronic invoicing is restricted. The restrictions will last about 34 months.
  2. 2022—2023The tax office issues eight orders lifting the restrictions. Not one is carried out.
  3. 28 Apr 2023On the tax authority's claim, a court declares the contract void (case no. 3514-23-00-2/894); the company was the defendant.
  4. 19 Jul 2023The judgment becomes final. The law spells out the tax consequences of a void transaction for the buyer — but not for the seller.
  5. Dec 2023A corrective VAT return is filed on paper but never registered in the state information system. Further filings in February and July 2024 meet the same fate.
  6. Aug—Oct 2025The administrative court returns the claim without examining its substance; the appeal court upholds that decision.
  7. Feb 2026A complaint to the Minister of Finance passes through nine internal referrals and lands with the very officials it was directed against.
  8. 1 Jul 2026A new Constitution enters into force, introducing an express right to compensation by the state for unlawful acts of public bodies (art. 15 § 6).
  9. 14 Jul 2026The first response on the merits in five years. The Ministry of Finance rejects the claims as time-barred but officially confirms, for the first time, that the tax returns were in fact filed.
  10. 20 Jul 2026A civil claim for damages of 167,949,135.65 ₸ is registered — case no. 1912-26-3-1/2137. On 27 Jul 2026 the court returns it over the court-fee deferral; a private appeal follows.
  11. 15 Sep 2026The Ministry of Finance issues an act that, in the company's view, leaves the refund question unresolved: its explanation of the refund procedure is described as given «for information purposes only».
  12. 22 Sep 2026The appeal court upholds the return of the company's administrative claim.

Why this matters beyond one company

The dispute is not about the court's finding that the contract was void. It is about what follows from it: the law spells out the tax consequences of a void transaction for the buyer but not for the seller, and the seller's corrective returns were never registered. Complaints to supervisory bodies were repeatedly routed back to the bodies being complained about (14 of 20 petitions in 2023–2026).

Every claim on this site is backed by an official document bearing a state registration number, published in full and open to verification.

Primary documents

About this page. This is a condensed summary prepared for readers outside Kazakhstan. The authoritative version of the case, with full legal reasoning and every source document, is the Russian-language case file. Where the two differ, the Russian version governs. Document titles, registration numbers and party names are given in their original form so they can be verified against Kazakhstani state systems.

Contact

Nikolay Chigrinov — director, Network Administrator LLP.
Nikolay@chigrinov.kz · +7 777 230-92-22
Enquiries from journalists, lawyers and researchers are answered personally, usually within a day. Materials may be republished without prior permission.